SEPOY.net
No Result
View All Result
Saturday, July 19, 2025
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Travel
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Travel
No Result
View All Result
SEPOY.NET
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

One key difference between a builders’ risk policy and a liability policy

Nicholas by Nicholas
August 30, 2022
in Business
0

Starr Insurance & Reinsurance Limited does not have to defend its insured in a Quebec construction case, because its builders’ risk policy is essentially a property policy, not a liability policy, Quebec’s Superior Court has ruled.

READ ALSO

How brokers dial in client trust

Quebec grapples with back-to-back thunderstorms, floods this week 

In construction, a builders’ risk policy typically covers the costs of repairing an unfinished structure or replacing building materials when weather, fire, vandalism or theft hits a construction site.

“The court first noted that the Civil Code of Québec provides for two types of damage insurance: liability, and property,” Nathan Hassan Omar of Robinson Sheppard Shapiro LLP commented in an Aug. 30 article on Mondaq. “[Quebec Superior Court] Justice Andres C. Garin observed the legal obligation to take up an insured’s defence…applies exclusively to liability insurance.

“Justice Garin then observed that builder’s risk policies are usually property insurance policies. After examining Starr’s policy, the court concluded that it was in fact a property insurance policy that did not provide for the insurer’s obligation to take up its insured’s interest in case of a claim or lawsuit.”

In Bridor inc. c. 90784497 Québec inc., the Superior Court ruled on a fundamental distinction between a builders’ risk policy — which is designed to prevent subcontractors on a construction project from having to sue each other to recover costs for property damage in the event of a claim — and a liability insurance policy.

Bridor, a company specializing in the bakery and pastry products industry, wished to expand its factory in Boucherville, Que., and gave Construction Mikado the contract to supervise the expansion work, according to the court decision, released July 5.

Starr Insurance & Reinsurance Ltd. insured the project under a builders’ risk policy and a ‘wrap-up’ policy, which offers global worksite civil liability insurance.

On May 26, 2021, Bridor filed a lawsuit against Mikado and Starr, claiming:

  • $982,708 from Mikado for poor management of the project;
  • $1 million compensation for damage to the architectural ‘sandwich panels’ that formed the exterior walls of the expansion at the Bridor plant; and
  • $516,752 in damages for improper finishing of the expansion’s concrete slab.

Bridor also seeks Starr’s joint and several liability with respect to the last two heads of claim.

None of Bridor’s allegations have been proven in court.

Mikado brought a Wellington-type application against Starr, asking the court to require Starr to defend it against Bridor’s second allegation concerning the sandwich panels. Mikado’s Wellington claim relied exclusively on the builders’ risk construction site policy issued by Starr, not the wrap-up policy.

“It appears from the structure of the [Civil Code of Quebec] that the insurer’s legal obligation to defend its insured applies only in matters of liability insurance,” the Quebec Superior Court wrote in its decision.

“That the duty to defend should be so limited makes perfect sense. The purpose of liability insurance is to protect the insured against the [financial] consequences of his contractual or extra-contractual civil liability. However, such civil liability is typically sought under the terms of a legal action against which the insured will have to defend himself, thus generating the defense costs that the insurer will have to assume.

“This reality is absent in the case of property insurance whose purpose is to compensate the insured for the material losses he suffers.”

The court went on to conclude:

“It follows that article 2503 [of the Civil Code of Quebec], which only applies to liability insurance, imposes no obligation on Starr to assume the defense of Mikado.

“Not only is there no legal duty to defend here, the construction site policy [i.e. the builders’ risk policy] contains no provision that imposes a contractual obligation on Starr to defend its insureds. Accordingly, Mikado’s Wellington claim, based on the site [policy], must fail.”

 

Feature image courtesy of iStock.com/Drazen_


Related Posts

How brokers dial in client trust
Business

How brokers dial in client trust

July 18, 2025
Quebec grapples with back-to-back thunderstorms, floods this week 
Business

Quebec grapples with back-to-back thunderstorms, floods this week 

July 18, 2025
How Canada’s latest resilience centre wound up in Toronto’s financial district
Business

How Canada’s latest resilience centre wound up in Toronto’s financial district

July 18, 2025
Strangers Things have happened: Netflix profits soar but investors are not happy
Business

Strangers Things have happened: Netflix profits soar but investors are not happy

July 18, 2025
Alberta brokers sound the alarm on auto insurance availability 
Business

Alberta brokers sound the alarm on auto insurance availability 

July 17, 2025
Latest delay in Jasper’s rebuild has insurers calling for a disaster recovery agency
Business

Latest delay in Jasper’s rebuild has insurers calling for a disaster recovery agency

July 17, 2025
Next Post

Hydrogen Water – What You Should Expect

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About

Sepoy.net is a perfect place for people who want daily updates on news related to business, technology, entertainment, health, cryptocurrency etc.

Contact: hello@sepoy.net

Major Categories

News

Business

Tech

Economy

 

Recent Posts

  • Play Fortunate Girls 100 aztec treasure pokie free spins percent free Zero Download free Trial
  • Da Vinci Diamonds’ Slot Opinion 2021: Wager Totally free & A slot very big goats online real income
  • Splash Cash Slots Opinion Enjoy It Online Game

Pages

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy

© 2023 Sepoy.net

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • News
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel

© 2023 Sepoy.net