Sepoy-logo
No Result
View All Result
Monday, October 2, 2023
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Travel
  • Home
  • News
  • Business
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
  • Economy
  • Crypto
  • Travel
No Result
View All Result
SEPOY.NET
No Result
View All Result
Home Business

Will insurance cover deductible when toilet overflows?

Nicholas by Nicholas
August 21, 2023
in Business
0
Will insurance cover deductible when toilet overflows?

A strata apartment owner is entitled to collect a deductible from the owner of the unit above his own, following a toilet overflow that caused substantial damages to his apartment, British Columbia’s Civil Resolution Tribunal (CRT) has determined.

In Meier v. Dietz, John Meier lives below Rositta Dietz in a strata building. Dietz’s toilet overflowed, causing over $80,000 in damage and forcing Meier to relocate for more than five months. Meier’s insurance covered the damage, minus a $1,000 deductible.

Meier claimed the deductible from Dietz, as well as Solus Trust Company Ltd., Dietz’s attorney under a power of attorney. Meier also asked that Dietz be required to pay his deductible if a similar occurrence happened in the future.

CRT vice chair Eric Regehr noted there was no direct evidence from Dietz in this dispute.

“Often, when a party fails to provide clearly relevant evidence, the CRT will draw an adverse inference,” meaning CRT will assume evidence was not provided because it would not be helpful.

No party disputed the facts of the complaint: On Aug. 23, 2021, there was a substantial blackwater leak that originated in Dietz’s bathroom and caused extensive damage in Meier’s strata lot. And, Regehr noted, it’s well established the “upstairs neighbour in a multi-unit strata building owes their downstairs neighbour a duty of care.”

However, Regehr noted there was “no factual or legal basis for Mr. Meier to make a claim against [Dietz’s attorney] Solus,” and dismissed that specific claim.

So, the only question before the CRT was whether Dietz negligently caused the leak and is liable for the deductible.

Dietz argued there was no conclusive evidence of negligence. Civil claims in B.C. require an applicant (Meier in this case) to “prove their claim on a balance of probabilities.”

The strata hired Westech Plumbing and Heating to clear the blockage. The company’s invoice said the plumber dismantled the drainage pipes for Dietz’s toilet, which were accessed through Meier’s bathroom ceiling, and cleared out “excessive amounts of paper and wipes.”

Further, the plumber said the leak’s “main cause was lost down the pipe,” which Regehr interpreted to mean some portion of the blockage cleared on its own and was no longer visible.

“I find that the evidence clearly establishes that the source of the blackwater leak was Ms. Dietz’s toilet. I agree with Ms. Dietz that the evidence about what blocked the drainpipe is not entirely conclusive because the blockage had partially cleared. In other words, it may not have been the paper and wipes the plumber observed,” Regehr wrote.

“Still, I find that the evidence establishes that the toilet likely overflowed after Ms. Dietz flushed it, based on the location and description of the partial blockage and lack of any obvious alternative cause. Given the toilet overflowed enough to cause extensive damage to Mr. Meier’s strata lot, I find that Ms. Dietz likely did not monitor the toilet after flushing. I therefore find that her conduct fell below the applicable standard of care, and that she is liable for Mr. Meier’s deductible.”

The CRT ordered Dietz to pay Meier $1,169.88 to cover $1,000 in damages, $44.89 in pre-judgment interest, and $125 in CRT fees.

Beyond the damages awarded, Meier had claimed $104.31 for a water sensor to detect future leaks, and $45 for the cost of ‘expert evidence.’ Regehr dismissed those claims.

Meier also asked for an order that Dietz be automatically liable for his deductible, now $2,500, in the event of a future leak. “I decline to make an order about a hypothetical event. Ms. Dietz’s liability for a future leak will depend on whether she was negligent, as it was here,” Regehr said.

 

Feature image by iStock.com/Marvin Samuel Tolentino Pineda


READ ALSO

Fostering Resilience: The Crucial Role of Trust in Your Insurance Partner

10 Preliminary Questions Broker Should ask their Commercial Specialty Clients

Related Posts

Fostering Resilience: The Crucial Role of Trust in Your Insurance Partner
Business

Fostering Resilience: The Crucial Role of Trust in Your Insurance Partner

October 1, 2023
10 Preliminary Questions Broker Should ask their Commercial Specialty Clients
Business

10 Preliminary Questions Broker Should ask their Commercial Specialty Clients

October 1, 2023
Unlocking Profits: The Power of Vehicle History Data in Insurance
Business

Unlocking Profits: The Power of Vehicle History Data in Insurance

October 1, 2023
51st Annual Vehicle Crimes Conference – Save The Date
Business

51st Annual Vehicle Crimes Conference – Save The Date

September 29, 2023
How generative AI is enabling cyber criminals
Business

How generative AI is enabling cyber criminals

September 29, 2023
Are your tenant insurance clients fully covered?
Business

Are your tenant insurance clients fully covered?

September 29, 2023
Next Post
Do ChatGPT and Bard spell the demise of SEO?

Do ChatGPT and Bard spell the demise of SEO?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

POPULAR NEWS

Roblox Is Unbreakable Trello Is this safe?

Roblox Is Unbreakable Trello Is this safe?

November 4, 2022
Discord Registered Games  Discord Registered Gaming You need to join the Club

Discord Registered Games Discord Registered Gaming You need to join the Club

November 4, 2022
How To Chose the Right Data Analytics Program

How To Chose the Right Data Analytics Program

November 4, 2022
Heavy explosion on market square in Halle – three injured

Heavy explosion on market square in Halle – three injured

November 4, 2022

Shivon Zilis Wiki, Height, Age, Boyfriend, Husband, Family, Biography & More

July 11, 2022

EDITOR'S PICK

Letter from Istanbul: Erdoğan is now backing Assad

August 25, 2022
Peripheral tumor biomarkers to guide treatment for HPV-associated malignancies

Peripheral tumor biomarkers to guide treatment for HPV-associated malignancies

August 15, 2023
Landtagswahl in Hessen: AfD-Politik schadet AfD-Wählern

Landtagswahl in Hessen: AfD-Politik schadet AfD-Wählern

September 23, 2023
Coinbase Stock at All-Time Low as Market Falls

Coinbase Stock at All-Time Low as Market Falls

November 22, 2022

About

Sepoy.net is a perfect place for people who want daily updates on news related to business, technology, entertainment, health, cryptocurrency etc.

Contact: [email protected]

Major Categories

News

Business

Tech

Economy

 

Recent Posts

  • Start Codon invites life sciences leaders, founders, and investors to Innovation Showcase 2023
  • Mann soll Frau und gemeinsames Kind gezielt angefahren haben
  • Mastering the Game: How to Fix Your Golf Swing

Pages

  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Disclaimer
  • DMCA
  • Home
  • Privacy Policy

© 2023 Sepoy.net

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Business
  • News
  • Health
  • Tech
  • Science
  • Lifestyle
  • Travel

© 2023 Sepoy.net

x